Cedarhurst is an early Huntsville house that now serves as the clubhouse of a townhome community. It is better known for its ghost than for its architecture. Huntsville’s most famous ghost story is the tale of Sally Carter, a 15-year-old visitor who died there in 1837, and of a toppled tombstone in 1919. This guide covers the history of the house, the legend and its variations, what the record can and cannot support, and why the mansion cannot be visited.

A short history of Cedarhurst
Cedarhurst was built by Stephen S. Ewing, a Huntsville banker and businessman. According to an account in the Heritage of Madison County, republished by the Huntsville History Collection, Ewing bought the land on December 13, 1823, from Ebenezer Titus, and the house is thought to have been completed in 1825. The account says it was built in two sections: the four front rooms are 19 feet 6 inches square with walls 19 inches thick, while the three rear rooms have walls 15 inches thick. It also notes original wide-plank floors, brass rim locks and handmade window glass in the dining room. The property stood on a hillside in a grove of old trees, and one account says it was named for the cedars lining the drive.
Ewing sold the house on December 12, 1865, to Robert C. Brickell, and moved to Mississippi. It then passed through several families, including the Doyle, Tardy, Davis, Hughes and Gwin families. In 1919 J. D. Thornton and his wife bought it with 350 acres. In the 1980s a developer bought the property for a townhome community and kept the house as the clubhouse. Today it is a private clubhouse within a residential community, near Drake Avenue in southeast Huntsville.
The legend of Sally Carter
Sally Carter was a real person. She was born in November 1821 and died at Cedarhurst on November 28, 1837, less than three weeks before her 16th birthday. She was visiting her sister, Mary Ewing, and died of an illness after a short time in an upstairs bedroom. She was buried in the family cemetery on the property.
The 1919 tombstone story
The best-known ghost story is dated to 1919. According to local lore, a 17-year-old cousin of Mrs. Thornton named Charles Roland, visiting from Dothan, slept on a cot outside the room where Sally had died. During a violent thunderstorm he dreamed, or experienced, a visit from a teenage girl who said she was Sally Carter and asked him to set her tombstone upright because the storm had blown it over. At breakfast the family laughed and teased him, but they walked to the little cemetery and found the stone lying on the ground. Roland reportedly returned to Dothan at once and never came back. Some retellings say the stone was left lying, which is offered as a reason for later unrest.
Earlier and later reports
The same county account says the first report of Sally’s return was earlier, in the time of the Davis family. A woman who was young at the time, speaking about fifty years afterward, said she heard someone climbing the stairs on a sunny day and ran, and was told it was only Sally. After 1919, the account says, one long-term roomer slept in Sally’s room for seven years and described thrown ashtrays and a bolt found unlocked, and that Mrs. Thornton herself never saw an apparition.
The story reached a wider audience in the 1960s and 1970s, when a local ghost craze made visiting Sally Carter’s grave at night a teenage rite of passage. A Huntsville Times column says a well-trodden path led to the grave, and that vandalism and pranks were common, including a fire in the Cedarhurst garage. The county account says pieces were chipped from her gravestone until little was left.
After the clubhouse opened to the public for about two weeks in 1985 as a decorator showcase, the account says, a room dressed for Sally with ribbons, silk flowers and a diary was twice found disturbed. It also describes a door that slammed and locked at a 1989 class reunion and footsteps heard upstairs before a 1990 wedding. These are reports in a 1994 retelling and cannot be verified. Guests who stay at the clubhouse are said to hear footsteps and a door closing softly.
The graves and Maple Hill Cemetery
In December 1982, when the townhome development began, Sally Carter’s grave and the graves of her sister, Mary Ewing, and Mary’s three children were excavated and moved, according to the Huntsville Times. The family did not disclose the new location of Sally’s grave. A 2024 al.com article says Sally was reinterred in an unmarked grave at Huntsville’s Maple Hill Cemetery, but the earlier reports say only that the location was not disclosed. The county account adds that the crew found Mary Ewing’s vault but no trace of a vault for Sally, and that some people wonder whether she was ever buried there.
What the record can and cannot support
The house, Stephen Ewing, the sale to Robert Brickell and the 1980s conversion are documented in local histories and newspaper reporting. Sally Carter’s name and death date are recorded by the Huntsville History Collection. The ghost stories are a different matter. The 1919 story was told and retold decades later, with no contemporary source in the material read, and the 1960s legend-tripping craze did more to spread it than any document did.
The tellings also disagree. Some say the 1919 guest slept on a cot outside Sally’s room, and others place him in an upstairs bedroom. One ghost-lore web page moves the tombstone episode to a thunderstorm in the 1950s and calls the guest a visitor sleeping upstairs. The house’s construction is dated 1823 in some accounts and 1825 in others. Sally’s burial place after 1982 is called undisclosed in some sources and Maple Hill in others, including a 2024 al.com article and an Alabama Heritage photo caption, and the county account says no vault was found for her, which leaves open whether she was ever buried at the site. Several web pages about Cedarhurst add details with no source, and they should not be treated as confirmation. The Huntsville Times column and the county heritage account are the most detailed accounts read.
Visiting Cedarhurst
Cedarhurst Mansion cannot be visited as a tourist site. Alabama Heritage says the property is closed to the general public, and a 2024 al.com article says it is a clubhouse for a gated community and is not open to the public. The research for this guide did not find an official community or city page confirming access rules, so treat the gate and security as reported rather than confirmed. Do not trespass, and do not look for the old cemetery site. The Huntsville Times says police or fire crews were occasionally called during the legend-tripping years.
Practical tips
- Cedarhurst itself: private property inside a residential community. No public hours, admission or tours were found as of October 25, 2026.
- Maple Hill Cemetery: Huntsville’s historic city cemetery is at 203 Maple Hill Drive SE, Huntsville, AL 35801. The cemetery department’s office is open Monday to Friday, 7am to 4pm, according to the City of Huntsville, and its phone is 256-427-5730. Sally Carter’s grave is reported to be unmarked and its location undisclosed, so there is no marker to find.
- The photo above: it shows Maple Hill Cemetery, not the mansion, because no free photograph of Cedarhurst could be found.
FAQ
Is Cedarhurst Mansion haunted?
According to local lore, the ghost of Sally Carter, who died there in 1837, haunts the house. The best-known story dates to 1919 and cannot be checked against a contemporary source.
Who was Sally Carter?
A real person who was born in November 1821 and died at Cedarhurst on November 28, 1837, while visiting her sister, Mary Ewing.
Can you visit Cedarhurst Mansion?
No. Sources read describe it as a private clubhouse in a gated community, closed to the general public.
Where is Sally Carter buried?
Her grave was moved in December 1982. Some sources say the new location was not disclosed, and a 2024 article says she is in an unmarked grave at Maple Hill Cemetery.
Who built Cedarhurst?
Stephen S. Ewing, who bought the land in 1823. The house is thought to have been completed in 1825.
More haunted houses: For other Southern houses with ghost traditions, see Gaineswood in Demopolis, Alabama, Captain Mulls House in Hollygrove, Arkansas and The Bell House.
Sources
- Huntsville History Collection: Stephen S. Ewing: the Cedarhurst house description and the 1994 retelling printed in the county heritage book.
- Huntsville History Collection: Sally Carter: birth, death and burial notes.
- al.com, The Huntsville Times: Huntsville’s Halloween Legend (2007): the 1982 grave removal, the legend-tripping era and the 1919 story.
- Alabama Heritage: The Myth of Sally Carter (2024): the legend and the statement that the property is closed to the public.
- al.com: Alabama urban legends (2024): the gated clubhouse, the unmarked Maple Hill burial and the legend-tripping note.
- Nightbringer.se: The haunted America: a ghost-lore page with a short Cedarhurst entry, used for the 1950s variant.
- City of Huntsville: City Cemeteries: Maple Hill address, phone and office hours, read October 25, 2026.
Shop the gear
- Haunted Mansions in the Heart of Dixie (book)
- Haunted Castles, Haunted Mansions, Haunted Houses (book)
NicheStuff is our own shop; some links in this post go to products we sell.
Top image: Maple Hill Cemetery in Huntsville, Alabama. It is shown because no free photo of Cedarhurst Mansion could be found and is not the mansion. Photo by LonelyPilgrim via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5.
